State Farm® Insurance Agent Jerry Doherty

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.

Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

Review on google Review on facebook Review on yelp

What our customers say about us...

barbie brown

June 13, 2024

1 out of 5

"This review is for Leigh Ann and State Farm in general. I was involved In a freak accident leaving work 6/12/24 at 7:30 pm. A truck hit a light pole and it fell on top of my car and I am lucky to be alive. The last thing you want to do is deal with insurance. I wish it was that easy. I called State Farm and made a claim. I was told that a tow truck was on its way. I was stranded on a bad side of town at a BP. I called State Farm and I spent hours on hold and couldn’t get anyone to answer the phone. I kept receiving automated messages about how they were experiencing higher than normal call volumes. I literally couldn’t get a hold of one human from State Farm. I waited for over 4 hours and finally found a ride home. Imagine almost being killed by a freak accident and sitting in a gas station alone and your insurance company is nowhere to be found. I wanted to go home and process what had happened. I called Jerry’s office today and got a voicemail. 5 minutes later I received a text that my tow truck was on the way. I waited 2 hours and called back but blocked my number this time. Leigh Ann answered the phone and I explained my frustrations. I received no apology whatsoever. She was raising her voice and making excuses for everything that happened. Guess what happened next? She hung up on me. I see this is a trend for this office based in the previous google reviews. She admitted she has never had someone experience this negligence in the 12 years she has worked there, yet accepted zero responsibility or an apology. I will admit I was raising my voice too but it was because I couldn’t believe she had the audacity to talk to me like that after what I had been through. I really hope that Jerry can contact me and explain what happened. “Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there?” You were nowhere to be found and I this has been a horrible experience."

We responded:

"Barbie, thank you for taking the time to share your experience. First and foremost, we are incredibly relieved to hear that you are safe after such a terrifying incident. We sincerely apologize for the distress and frustration you experienced during and after the accident. Your feedback is essential to us, and we are very sorry for the lack of timely support and the communication issues you encountered. We want to make this right and restore your confidence in our service, please feel free to give us a call at (614) 461-7833 so we can discuss this further. -Jerry"

Stevie Armbrester

November 10, 2023

3 out of 5

"The lady helping here is so down to earth & kind its a mind blowing experience because people in customer service don't seem to exist like her anymore as state farm is spiraling downward🙃"

We responded:

"We appreciate you taking the time to leave our State Farm Insurance Office a Google review! We're glad to hear that our team was able to provide you with a high level of customer service. We hope you have a safe and relaxing Thanksgiving! - Jerry Doherty State Farm Insurance, Columbus OH "

Dorothy Hedges

January 27, 2023

5 out of 5

"Jerry has been my insurance agent for over forty years at least. Always the best service. I wouldn't change companies no matter the cost. Best company ever!"

We responded:

"Thank you very much Dorothy for taking the time today to leave our State Farm office a 5 star Google review. It has been our pleasure to assist you with your insurance needs over the last 40 years. I still remember signing you up to work with us in April of 1977. Thanks for recommending us and we look forward to working with you again this year! - Jerry"

Jessica Seckel

October 27, 2020

5 out of 5

"Have been using forever and they always are super helpful. You will always get a friendly voice on the other end of the phone."

Trista Turley

October 22, 2020

5 out of 5

"I’ve had various policies through this office for five years. Leigh Anne in the office is so responsive and easy to work with. She’s usually able to get me what I need in a matter of minutes."

Samantha Hoselton

October 4, 2019

5 out of 5

"I have been with this agency for 2 years. We have multiple policies and I haven’t had any negative service. They are very professional and I do recommend them!"

Jimmy EY

September 14, 2018

5 out of 5

"Very nice and knowledgeable staff. Have recommended their office to many people."

Wynter Rose

February 8, 2018

5 out of 5

"Customer service is awesome! Very responsive, reliable and service oriented."

ricksUTUBE (Rick Shuster)

January 29, 2015

5 out of 5

"Both Jerry and Monica from this office have been incredibly helpful and real troopers helping get us settled with multiple lines and several states - tremendous assistance with getting Columbus newbies all taken care of in new home city. Absolutely would recommend this office for all your insurance needs!"

Luis Avellana

January 12, 2024

1 out of 5

"*** This review is only on the people working at this office alone and not State Farm as a whole. *** *** I have been hung up on 2 days in a row by this office and told I was rude for calling and asking questions about claim *** As I currently navigate a claim with State Farm, I have been hung up on 2 days in a row by this office by 2 individuals. First I was hung up on by Leigh Anne yesterday (01/11/2024), no effort was made to come back into contact (in a scenario were maybe we were disconnected), once I called back in I was told the phone system booted her off of my call and into a new call. That their phone system is off of cellular and not land line and that it's a known issue in the office. Today (01/12/2024) I call back in to ask some follow up questions and for some assistance on my claim. Today I speak with Misty who in our conversation told me I was being rude.. a complete shock to me. Hearing this I ask her "I'm sorry but what have I've said this far or this week that has been rude". She proclaims "You've called us all week to ask questions." Shortly there after she also hangs up on me. I call back and ask why our call ended. She states "I've told you what I was going to do on your behalf there's nothing else I can do". I explain "I do have additional questions to ask and need to do a couple other things in our call. I never communicated that all my questions were asked/answered and said 'thank you have a great day' simply because the interaction wasn't done." She explains "I'm sorry I thought there was nothing else I could help you with". She eventually admits in the call there's no other way but to interpret the last call as anything but her hanging up on me. Since from my perspective this is the 2nd day in a row I've been hung up on by this office, I ask her about the phones in the office as it relates to any known issues. I ask, "are there any known issues with your current phone system in office, either disconnecting calls or dropping it?" She says "no, there's nothing wrong with our phones. We don't know of anything being wrong with our phones here in office. I apologize for hanging up you earlier today." I explain to her how Leigh Anne attributed our phone call yesterday ending early (her hanging up on me) due to a known issue with the phones. I followed up with explaining I've now been hung up on 2 days in a row. I asked that Jerry reach out to me so I can discuss the experience I have had with their specific office. Both for being called rude for in her words "calling and asking questions" in regards to my claim and being hung up on 2 days in a row by 2 different people."

We responded:

"Luis, we’re sorry for the situation you are currently in. I reviewed the call log and we recorded 56 minutes of total talk time with you. I did speak with Claims regarding your situation. I called you yesterday and left you a voicemail, feel free to call me back at 614-461-7833 so I can assist you with your frustration."

Kim Tilley

June 13, 2023

5 out of 5

"Leigh Anne Tudor was amazing helping me find the right policy for me !!! And believe me I knew nothing about life insurance other than I had to have it so my daughters would not have to ever worry about putting me to rest ! Thank you so much !!! If I could give 10 stars I would !"

We responded:

"Thank you for taking the time to leave our State Farm Insurance Office a 5 star Google review, Kim! I'm so glad to hear Leigh Ann was able to assist you with your insurance policy with us. Life Insurance can be convoluted at times so we pride ourselves in taking our time with each customers life insurance requests so they can feel confident in the plan they sign up for. We look forward to working with you and we hope you have a great rest of your week!- Jerry Doherty State Farm Insurance Office"

Greg Winchester

June 1, 2021

5 out of 5

"I've been with Jerry Doherty on and off since 2001. Everyone I've talked to has always been courteous and professional, from Monica to Misty. They are always available, or they get back to me very quickly. Way to go!"

We responded:

"Thank you for taking the time to write us a 5 star review Greg! Pleased to hear that you had an enjoyable insurance experience with our office. We're always hear to help you with your insurance needs. Be sure to tell your friends and family to give the Jerry Doherty State Farm Insurance team a call as well, we would love to help them out! - Jerry"

Linda C

October 24, 2019

5 out of 5

"This office has been great to work with. I greatly appreciate your help."

Mike Thomas

December 8, 2018

1 out of 5

"Working with this office was the worst experience with an insurance agency I've ever had. Monica lacks any ability to follow through or respond to any requests. Everything she informed me regarding a landlord policy for my rental was either inaccurate or misleading. I would strongly recommend avoiding this agency."

Queenie Babydoll

August 20, 2018

1 out of 5

"TERRIBLE!!! I have had problems with them since 2016. The customer service is just disgusting! Leanna has been rude to me over the phone several times, and had even hung up in my face. This is NOT professional, and you all should be ashamed of yourselves!!!"

Dawn Butler Mbomyo

July 10, 2014

5 out of 5

"I have been insured with this agent for about 8 years and have consistently received excellent service -- no matter if it is a small issue or a large one -- from rental car insurance, to accident claims, to policy details -- I have always received prompt, clear, and friendly service from this agent and the office staff."